2 Sep 2010

Roamin’ Round Darwin on a Pushie.

Posted by Mike Rubbo

That’s what they call a bike in Darwin, a Pushie, way up at the Top End of Australia.

Most people go to Darwin as a jumping off place for Kakadu.

Me, I went to ride bikes.

I’d heard a very curious thing, that in the Northern Territory, you could ride a bike, under certain conditions, without a helmet.

Why get excited about that? My European and Asian readers will be thinking. “We do it all the time where WE live, and perfectly legally.”

Well, in this protective cocoon we Aussies call home, it’s against the law to be helmet-less, for our own good, of course.

The cops could be anywhere, waiting to nab you and slap on a $154 fine, and demerit points as well!

It’s been that way since the early nineties, since the Hawke Govt, in many ways so good, bullied the States into imposing this new restraint on cyclists.

I wonder what Bob Hawke thinks about his law today?

Now, we are so conditioned to think that a helmet is part and parcel of safe cycling, that many people regard it as virtual suicide to ride anywhere without one, even on a protected cycleway.

Believe it or not, this photo of a woman on a Darwin Cycle path, will upset many Australians so much that they can become very angry at the absurd risk this woman is running.

My Darwin visit made it to the local paper, The NT News, recently voted the best paper in the whole region.

Here’s some reactions, comments, left on the online article re my proposal that perhaps the rest of the country had something to learn from Darwin, bikewise.

You’d think they’d be pleased. Not at all!

“Helmets are also needed on the cycle paths! …….
seeing him ( a rider on a cycle path who’d collided with a walker) frothing at the mouth and bleeding all over the path, is something that will stay with me forever, and I will ALWAYS wear a helmet when riding my bike.”

…. should be forced to visit any hospital where there will always be kids and adults who have suffered horrendous brain injury from being clobbered by a hard surface.

Given this intense feeling, it comes as a great surprise to find that it’s actually legal to ride without a stack hat here, as long as you stick to the great cycleways they’ve built….. (70 Kms. of them so far!)

…….and, this is the strange part, to the footpaths.

Yes, you are allowed to ride on the footpaths, sharing right of way with pedestrians. How’s that possible I wondered? You just work it out.

It’s a recipe for bloodshed, you’d think and yet, ( and Harold Scrooby will disagree) it seems to work surprisingly well.

True, the footpaths are not that crowded. Darwin is like a country town in some ways.

These two old friends meet every morning for their walk. I swung round them carefully.

Here’s me on a footpath , downtown Darwin

Of course I was bound to like it, wasn’t I? But I did interview pedestrians, usually just after a bike had swooshed past, and found that few were upset.

One woman, she was a obviously a motorist, said. “Better they be on the footpath than on the roads where we have to dodge around them and worry about hitting them.”

This fellow from Melbourne was surprised that it was not a problem

Most walkers agreed that cyclists did ring their bells and usually rode slowly. My borrowed bike, had no bell but squeaky brakes did the job.

So, how come there’s this bit of freedom at the Top End when the rest of us have to wear our lids, like it or not?

I heard various explanations. One bike shop owner claimed that a woman in Alice Springs, also in the NT, had gone to court to win the right of riding without a helmet because of the heat.

She’d won the case and that had set the precedent.

Whilst no one would confirm this story, when I asked bare headed cyclists why they preferred to ride that way, many said, yes, it was partly because of the heat. So, an exemption stemming from that, makes sense

But, having got used to it, many said they loved the freedom of the wind in their hair, of all their senses being more open to the elements.

Some folks urged me to come back and ride in the rainy season. They claimed there’s nothing like riding bare headed in tropic rain.

My next question to Darwin pushie riders had to be this….

“Since helmets are sold to the rest of the country on the basis of danger, the fear of brain injury, “Arn’t you afraid?”

No one I spoke to was particularly afraid. Not on the cycle paths and footpaths, that is. But many said they wouldn’t ride on the roads, helmeted or not.

Indeed, I saw riders coming to a road to cross, and then pushing their bike across the intersection to the next footpath.

Darwin riders have got used to their freedom , though some were a bit hazy as to exactly what the law was.

I was able to explain that, legally, You can only ride, helmet free, on the cycle paths and the footpaths.

On the roads, you must wear a helmet, though the consensus is that the cops have better things to do than hassle bare headed cyclists.

I did see some riders who seemed to be in the wrong place legally, or were about to be.

But my impression is that most people obeyed the law.

The upshot, I discovered is that there are two distinct bike cultures in Darwin. No, not law breakers and law abiders, but…….

(1) road cyclists and (2) footpath cyclists.

The road cyclists look very much like they do all over the country, hunched over their drops and, not only helmeted, but often in Lycra.

They’ll tell you the helmet is a safety issue for them. But some will also admit that without a helmet, they feel undressed.

The helmet is part of the look. It’s about performance too, about the air flowing smooth over your skull at speed. These riders, like sports cyclists everywhere else, want to go fast.

The other tribe, the bare headed ones, are always in their regular clothes, no Lycra for them, usually with a back pack.

They’re away from traffic, and are riding, most of the time I observed, much slower.

Some foot-path riders do wear helmets but they still belong to the second tribe in speed and general demeanor

True, the two groups are neither equal nor pure. There are many more helmet wearers than bare heads, about 70-30 I’d say, and there were lots of helmet wearers on the cycle paths, more than I expected.

Surprisingly, I did not see a single rider with a helmet dangling from the handle bars. Surprising, since you’d think that riding bare headed on the path, you might need one when you switched to the road.

I concluded that most bare headers are determined to make their whole journey that way, which is possible given the cycleway/footpath combination.

Darwinians are lucky in that their cycle paths, whilst often in a beautiful location, along the water for example, also go somewhere useful. They head in and out of town. David Hembrow would find this makes sense.

Southern cycle paths are often just leisure circuits, which is a huge planning mistake

So, I’m on Darwin’s streets and cycle paths for four days, Thursday to Sunday. I begin to see patterns.

Far more women are riding here than in my home state, NSW. This fits with the removal of fear idea, since women always cite fear as a major reason not to ride a bike.

I note, that many of these women are Asian, a group I’ve never noticed on bikes down South.

When I ask the locals, they explain that many of the Asian women who work in food service jobs and hotels round town, ride bikes to work.

I speak to several and find it’s true.

This may an important upside of the helmet exemption, enticing groups onto bikes who normally don’t ride.

We do know that when compulsory helmets came in, in the early nineties, they cut cycling by between 3o- 40%, so the reverse can be true.

But what about the down side? If the helmet advocates are right, there should be a higher head injury rate here, especially amongst the second group.

It turns out that the opposite is true. The accident rate for cyclists in the NT, accidents which would put you in hospital, is 23 per 100,000 population, exactly the national average. (2006-7 figures)

But when you also discover that NT roads are much more dangerous for vehicles generally, and that’s a statistical fact, bikes turn out to be safer to ride in Darwin than elsewhere.

They are also more frequently used to get to work. The bike commuting rate at 4.2%, in Darwin, is four times the national average. (Thanks to Chris Gilham for supplying these stats.)

Apropos of accidents, I spoke to Darren at Scooter World a place which rents mountain bikes to tourists. These are some of his rental bikes out front.

(I tell him that I wish he’d offer some sit-up bikes, a style on which everyone is comfortable.

Perhaps a new film, Eat Pray Love, featuring Julia Roberts on this stately bike, will open our eyes to what we are missing, bikewise )

But I digress. Darren tells me that in his nine years of rentals, he’s never had a customer with head injuries. Plenty of falls, scrapes, etc. but no head injuries. Seems like those most likely to be hurt are road using helmet wearers.

I followed this up at another bike shop downtown, The cycle Zone With some prompting, a guy working there recalled the last really nasty accident.

About a year ago, he told me, a rider was knocked off his bike by a car. Yes, he was a road rider and he was wearing a helmet.

In any case, you are safer on a bike than almost any other getting around activity, safer or as safe as being a pedestrian, for example.

In Holland, where the cycling conditions have been made close to ideal, your chances of a serious head/brain injury on a bike are once every 90 lifetimes.

And this is calculated on the average Dutch citizen exposing him/herself to this risk by cycling the impressive distance of 72,000 kms. in a lifetime. Ah, we must try harder!

I got this from David Hembrow’s very useful blog, A view from the Cycle Path

I said I found two bike cultures in Darwin. But wait, there is a third group which is very powerful in the debate, who are passionately pro helmet, and yet don’t ride fast.

Their support for helmets is very emotive and difficult to argue against. This photo should give you a clue as to who they are.

Yes, it’s the cycling parents of small children, determined to set a good example, determined their kids will grow up regarding helmets as essential as breathing.

They are amongst the law’s most fervent defenders.

I met a Doctor, Paul…. with a young family of three. He owns probably the only cargo bike in Darwin, a marvelous Dutch Gazelle Cubby.

When Paul’s family sets off for the market, littlest in the Cubby, they’ll be protected to the max.

Not only that, but it’s footpaths all the way.

I don’t know if it’s my persuasive powers, or just the powerful logic of helmet choice, but in the time we are together, Paul, the rusted on helmet guy that he is, comes around…. slightly

He’s always been vehemently opposed, he told me, to any relaxation of the helmet laws, but now he’s saying, having heard me out, that he could support certain exemptions, like Melbourne, and the one here.

I’d explained that I’d come to Darwin to get ammunition for another much needed helmet exemption.

The Melbourne Bike share scheme, 500 bikes for easy rental on the streets of that city, is in danger of failing because of our rigid helmet law. Why that is, is explained in previous posts.

We have been arguing on this blog that the riders of these inherently slower and safer bikes, both in Melbourne and soon in Brisbane, where Dr. Paul Martin is pushing the idea, should be able to choose.

They should be able to use one of the share bikes without a helmet as they can all over Europe, and as Paul Martin and his wife, Veronica, are doing here. Right, Paul?

But our attempts to promote this with a peaceful demo, got us stopped by the Melbourne police, ticketed, or so we thought.

Worse, our suggestion is mocked as both irresponsible and politically undo-able.

So, I’ve come to Darwin for proof that this is not true.

In a way, Paul is my most important encounter here. That this intelligent cyclist and helmet advocate, can come to see that our suggestion makes sense, is a gift.

But Paul remains adamant that those, like himself, who like to go fast (not on the Cubby but on his expensive Titanium bike) should not have a choice.

And for him, personally, there’ll never be choice.

As they wave me off, Paul, Megan the kids, I remember his smile as he said.

” Mike, even in Amsterdam I’d wear my helmet. And if I’m the only one, that’s fine. ”

Wife Megan agrees.

I’ll be going home in good shape for Melbourne, I feel, and with some startling news for the rest of the country.

My conclusion; It’s strongly indicated, Bicycle Victoria and Bicycle NSW please take note, that the Northern Territory pays no health penalty for allowing a degree of helmet freedom.

What do you say to that, you cycling bodies?

Here’s the NT’s superb Parliament building. What’s come up in the Parliament on pushies, I wonder?

I tried very hard to get a word from the Darwin police. Many phone calls to their media guy in the end. led to nothing. They’ve had their hands full with the Annual Arts Festival. I’m sure.

I had one question, a sort of two parter, for the police PR man.

The word I get from most cyclists is that you turn a blind eye to riders without helmets.

One can understand that you have your hands full with the very high car and motorcycle accident rate here, often fueled by alcohol.
Is it fair to say that, comparatively, pushbikes don’t present a problem?

Is it also correct to say that, when serious accidents do happen to bike riders, they tend to involve road riders wearing helmets, and so, cracking down on bare headed riders on footpaths, would not be productive?”

I never got to ask my leading question.

After, many kms. on my borrowed bike, loaded with movie equipment as well as my still camera, I’m ready for food and relaxation.

On the warf, in sight of our naval guardians….

…..I ate crumbed Barra, washed down with a drop of chilled Semillon. Delicious! and only 13 bucks for the fish

Then off, still on the bike of course, to the famous Mindil Beach Sunset Market

I meet the colorful, Swaggie Campbell. I take his address, Care of Wintermoon, Cameron’s Pocket, to send him the photo.

Campbells’s a bush poet who’s kind enough to recite Mulga Bill’s Bicycle ride for me. When the movie of my trip is done, you’ll see Campbell’s performance

Mindil beach, washed by the setting sun, is just over a low dune. An evening ritual has the locals watching the sun go down into the sea.

The temp’s gone down too, but it’s still very hot for me. Hmm, These fruit salads …..

…. at the stall of a girl who could perhaps be one of the cyclists I saw today, look very tempting .

I raised the idea with the Scooter Shop that Darwin should be promoting itself as a cycle tourism destination . “Is it being done?” I ask “No, manager said, but it’s a really good Idea.”

Even better, I found a third bike shop called, Deadly Treadlies, which plans to rent retro bikes soon, stately sit-ups. Now that’s the go!

I’ll be back to ride in the wet season, I vowed, to take a stately cycle for a sloshy spin. “Get in touch with your inner wet, and on wheels,” sounds like a slogan to intrigue.

You’d think, I’d be exhausted, and I am, but Darwin’s got me slightly intoxicated, the air, the smells, the people.

I can’t resist trying one last curiosity, The Deckchair Cinema, though I fall asleep in the movie.

Findings.
1. Enlightened helmet laws.
2. Impressive cycle path system.
3. No health penalty for helmet exemption.
4. Bike commuting rate, 3-4 times Nat. average. Due to exemption?
5. Leisure bike usage 1.7 times Nat. average

Mike Rubbo. Sept. 4th 2010

Subscribe to Comments

16 Responses to “Roamin’ Round Darwin on a Pushie.”

  1. Fascinating Mike!

    Those balmy evening scenes reminds me of my years living in Cairns.

    I think I need to go on a bicycle holiday to the top end.

    Looking forward to the film.

     

    Dr Paul Martin

  2. Wonderful article Mike! Looks like you had a fun adventure!

    This reminded me of my trip to Washington DC last year. They allow cyclists to use the footpaths everywhere except the busy downtown streets. Some of their footpaths were even marked as bike routes.

    However, despite the plethora of recreational trails and footpaths, I still received dirty looks for not wearing a helmet (and there is no helmet law there). Even on the recreational trail along the Potomac river people gave me dirty looks! It seemed that I was one of the very few people who wasn’t wearing a helmet!

    This just goes to show that the disdain for non-helmeted riders is drastically different in different areas with different cultures. I was completely shocked to see people visibly angry about someone else not wearing a helmet on a paved, off-road trail – even when there is no helmet law.

    It’s not like that here in Toronto. Sure, we have a few passionate helmet advocates here, but they are certainly in the minority. We also have a lot more non-helmeted riders here than I saw in DC (I believe 40% of riders wear helmets here in Ontario).

    Cheers,
    James / theurbancountry.com

     

    James

  3. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Darren, Amsterdamize, Tim Thomas, biketree, Mikael and others. Mikael said: Darwin & Northern Territory repealed their helmet law. Result? Cycling rates went up. Surprise surprise http://bit.ly/9GK1GR [...]

     
  4. James,

    I certainly get many dirty looks when out riding from everyone: car drivers, other cyclists and pedestrians. I’ve had cyclists (usually racer types) yell at me and a handful of pedestrians yell at me too (mostly the obese).

    It is strange that people feel the need to ‘remind’ me of the law – very peculiar.

     

    Dr Paul Martin

  5. The free advice you get from motorists and pedestrians is a curious little side-bar of cycling.

    Just the other week I was sitting waiting at a set of lights and some bloke walking down the footpath, right across the other side of a 4 lane major road, stopped and cursed me out, at length and using the strongest of language, for having no front light.

    In fact I do have a front light – an old-fashioned dynamo job, which throws out excellent beams when I am actually moving.

    As I say, this bloke was way the hell across the other side of a major road, on the footpath, going the other way, so my effect on his business was zero, and yet he felt perfectly entitled to give me a vituperative mouthful.

    I was also recently told off by some busybody female passerby for having my helmet strap too loose.

     

    Scott McIntyre

  6. Darwin looks like a great place to cycle. I think Darwin is important for Australia, because it’s a great example of a place where people can chose to wear a helmet or not, and the injury rates are no different from anywhere else, and maybe even lower because of the ‘slow ride’ philosophy riding without a helmet contributes to.

     

    Chris Rissel

  7. How strange, Scott, what do you think’s going on psychologically? Is it related to the over reaction on the helmet issue, I wonder. Mike

     

    Mike Rubbo

  8. Great article Mike. Very comprehensive. I didn’t know there was anywhere in Australia where sanity existed. We have been forced to holiday overseas to experience the exhilaration of ‘normal’ bike riding. Now we know we can book a flight to Darwin to once again ride with the wind in our hair the way we did when the freedom to cycle was as natural as breathing.

     

    Kathy Francis

  9. Kathy, what a great comment. You proved what I hoped, that there is tourist potential in this exemption, no matter for what reasons it was arrived at.

    Now, the next thing to be done in my book is, for there to be available for you to rent up there, a comfy sit-up bike so you can sail along, looking around and ahead and not at the road in front of you.

    Your handle bars will then sweep back, not pulling you forward into the semi lean so typical of Aussie bikes. I was reminded how important this was when in Darwin since the bike I was lent was a flat bar. To see Darwin, I had to ride, my head held painfully up all the time. I ended up having those vertical grips added to the handlebars, which helped a bit.

    I just cant understand why bike makers condemn riders to this unnecessary discomfort . Would anyone drive a car with their nose on the wheel?

     

    Mike Rubbo

  10. Hi Mike,
    Something strange happened to me today. I am in Christchurch, NZ (the place that has been badly shaken by an earthquake a couple of days ago). For the last two days I have been working in an area with significant damage I’ve been taking levels on the sewer manholes to determine just how much of the sewer system needs repairing or replacing. Anyway, they’ve been long days but I’ve enjoyed them as I feel as if I am contributing to the relief effort.
    The best way, by far, to get from home to my office is by bike. The traffic is terrible now (is traffic ever not) due to so many road closures. Last night I was on the way home making my way carefully past the cordoned off areas. I was riding slowly in the cycle lane (at the edge of the road) with my lights on (even though it wasn’t really that dark) when, believe it or not, I was stopped by a policeman (on a bike) and given a ticket ($55 fine) for not wearing a helmet.
    So, in case you haven’t seen anything about it in the news, here I am in Christchurch with hundreds of buildings damaged beyond repair, bridges and roads impassable, residents really scared (as the aftershocks have been regular and frightening) and I am fined for not riding with a helmet!!!!!!!!!
    The police officer even checked with his HQ to see if I’d been in trouble with the law before (I hadn’t). I was well dressed and riding an upright bike with mud guards that I use for getting around town. I must have been going about 10km/h.
    Amazing. I think I might move to Darwin. Do they get earthquakes there?
    Ross

     

    Ross

  11. @Ross

    It is sad and disappointing that the police deem that to be an important part of their job in such times.

    I really do believe that some of them think, “First it is no helmet, next it is complete anarchy…”.

    This is yet another example of why these laws need to go.

    I hope you all get back to some semblance of normal soon and keep up the good work. A bicycle is by far the best way to get around!

     

    Dr Paul Martin

  12. Hi All
    Just had request to copy my post from the melbourne share thread it may be helpful to see here – sorry for repeating here so just the main point is here.

    My advise is vote for the LDP. Libertarian policy is that victim-less crimes should not be punished and the LDP website specifically lists removing bicycle helmet laws on their website at ldp.org.au. check the Policy section under Victimless Crimes.

    I have met with them at their open monthly meeting here in SA, they are interested to help, and they need more members so if anyone is interested in the libertarian ideals it’s free and is online at ldp.org.au
    I don’t agree with every policy they have but this is an opportunity to get some political representation which no other party seems prepared to offer us.

    If Cyclists vote for and Support the LDP even if just for this one reason eventually the majors will take notice and we will see a change to the helmet laws sooner rather then later.

    Regards Steve.

     

    stephen

  13. What dont mind the name title in the last post it’s incorrect somehow i posted my message and the name came up as Dr Paul Martin !
    I am Stephen not Dr Paul Martin !

     

    stephen

  14. Darwin looks like a great place to go on holidays. A heaven for cyclist in Australia.

    Sorry to hear about the experience in Christchurch. Here’s a place to avoid. You’d think the police have got better things to do, that find better way to help, after an earthquake.

     

    Harvey

  15. just happened on this site – yes Dwn is great to cycle around – (I’ve been doing it for 22 yrs) even when its wet it isnt cold. however I have come off 4 times on bike paths, 3 times on my head – so yes I am an avid helmet enthusiast, and yes I was wearing a helmet each time I fell off – once you get used to it you dont even know its there. Many times I set off and think oh god I’ve fortotten my helmet only to reach up to feel it there – its just a cheapie so nothing special. i guess each to their own. I can see the problem with a shared bike enterprise around cities such as you mention.
    Be lovely to see Dwn as a bicycle tourist venue

     

    naomi

  16. Hi Mike,
    I just came across this post while searching for bicycle related articles about my town (Darwin…)

    Great post and a great blog I’m glad I stumbled across it!
    I found it amusing how you defined two cycling cultures in Darwin. It’s kind of amusing because the it reminded me of what is so special about living here in Darwin… Despite the various migrations of military staff, government workers and now, mining and construction personnel Darwin is still such an open minded free spirited place that we generally tend not to need to categorize ourselves into such rigid stereotypical roles.

    Despite it’s rapidly changing demographic, Darwin hasn’t yet lost it’s free spirited nature. Many of us who live here value dearly the fact that we live in a less regulated part of Australia than our countrymen (and Women) in other states are now used to.

    In some ways we are a little like cyclists in Copenhagen and Amsterdam who don’t tend to consider which category of cyclist they are… They just ride their bike because that’s how they get around. Of course there are always the exception to this but generally I’d say there are many cyclists here in Darwin who have never bothered to think at all about bicycle culture… It’s just a part of the culture.

    Regarding helmets I have to say that I am very glad that mandatory use of helmets is not law here. I love riding without a helmet and it definitely makes cycling generally more accessible. I truly appreciate the fact that I can choose whether or not I will wear a helmet. My choice is based on assessment of risk rather than fear of the law.

    I have several bicycles and ride for various reasons at different times, my reasons include.

    Commuting to and from work 15km trip each way per day
    – Touring – Very occasionally I go for a long ride approximate 150 km of road riding in a day.
    – Taking kids to school
    – Shopping
    – Leisure with the family

    Road riding – I always wear a helmet if I’m planning to ride on any major roadways. Commuting to work or touring. It makes sense to me that being in close proximity to speeding unaware drivers is potentially dangerous and I should take precautions to protect myself against driver error!

    Shopping – My local shops are close enough that I can avoid riding on major roads and so I don’t bother to wear a helmet to go shopping… It would be overkill and just add to the load

    School – My children must always wear a helmet and they never complain about this. It is actually law for children to wear helmets here… I don’t know what the age limits are. Even if it wasn’t I’d have them wear a helmet anyway because they do not have enough experience riding to be completely safe. So once again this decision is made according to risk… A more experienced rider is at far less risk of simply falling off under normal circumstances than someone who’s been riding for years… I may or may not wear a helmet myself when I ride the kids to school depending on what I am doing after.

    Leisure riding – Depends entirely on where we are going. If it’s just to the local playground I don’t bother to wear a helmet. If we’re planning a cycling adventure then I may wear one but generally not. When we take the kids we tend to avoid roads and ride quite slowly. No need for a helmet most of the time!

    Oh! it seems I’ve ranted on a bit so I’d better finish up!

    Basically riding is great in Darwin. However the biggest hazard is driver attitudes and there are some pretty bad ones up here. It can be quite dangerous on our roads and there is a general disregard for the safety of other human beings on our roads. Many pedestrians are hit.

    Another problem we face is lack of roadmanship from drivers and cyclists alike. I’ve seen so many young riders riding the wrong way which I am sure is due to lack of a simple understanding of safety. (they must think they are safer if they can look oncoming drivers in the eye!)

    I look forward to reading more of your posts.

     

    David F

Leave a Reply

Message: